Executive director and board relationship

Silence isn’t golden in a working relationship. When information flow dries up between executive directors and other board members, things go off the rails. Studies show that 40% of employees globally feel their organizations struggle with collaboration and communication. 

As a result, the board misses deadlines and ultimately, fails to fulfill day-to-day operations and the organization’s mission. All these factors lead to poor board effectiveness.

The board and executive director relationship is no different. Alack of transparency can have a serious downside: it destroys trust in executive leadership. In fact, 43% of on-site employees admit they’ve lost confidence in their executives because of poor communication. 

But here’s the good news: strong executive communications between the chief executive officer and the board chairs may improve the relationship between the board members. 

This article explores how clear communication bridges the gap between a frustrated board and a disconnected executive director. Here, we delve into their relationships: from the challenges and managing conflicts to exploring best practices. 

DOWNLOAD PDF

Importance of the executive director and board relationship

A strong relationship between the executive director and the board goes far beyond executive session board meetings. Here’s why organizations must take into account the board and executive relations:

1. Sharper decisions. When the leadership team shares their on-the-ground experience and the board offers their varied viewpoints, everyone has the information they need to make the best choices.
2. Streamlined daily operations. When everyone on the team understands their role, things run much smoother. The executive director focuses on daily operations, while the board keeps an eye on the long-term strategy.
3. Comfortable working climate. This isn’t just about strategy meetings, it’s about setting a clear direction for everyone. This, in turn, contributes to a sense of safety for the team, making it a more comfortable place to come to work every day.
4. More effective fundraising. A team that works well together inspires trust. As a result, donors are more likely to believe in your mission and contribute. 

Role of executive director vs. board of directors

Even though both the board and executive directors work for the benefit of the organization, their day-to-day tasks and areas of focus are quite different. 

Let’s compare them below:

Nonprofit board and executive director relationship

Across the world, the nonprofit sector encompasses over 10 million organizations dedicated to tackling society’s pressing issues, including poverty, hunger, environmental protection, and healthcare access.

To be effective, they are diversifying their fundraising efforts, and receiving financial support from a wider range of sources. Naturally, this growth corresponds to job creation and the effective use of digital channels to promote their work. 

However, despite this obvious positive outlook, nonprofits still face unique challenges in building strong relationships between their leadership teams. They frequently include limited resources, board member turnover, and challenges in making objective decisions.

Here’s a quick breakdown of how to build strong communication and transparency between the board and executive leadership. 

1. Everything starts with defining clear roles and responsibilities. For the best result, Forbes recommends using a RACI chart to prevent misunderstandings between nonprofit leadership.
2. Then, regular interactions, both formal board meetings and informal updates, help to stay connected and involved.
3. Nonprofits often operate with limited resources. So directors can bridge the communication gap by setting clear expectations and giving realistic budget projections and updates.  
4. Sometimes new board members can feel like outsiders with frequent turnover in the nonprofit sector. The executive director (ED) and board leadership should create onboarding programs and interact outside of formal settings. Thus, think about team-building activities or volunteer opportunities.
5. Despite the field, disagreements are natural. The key is to have a plan for addressing them in a healthy way. For that, a conflict resolution plan or mediation process fits the best. 

The issue of conflict between the board and executive director, and how to resolve it

Leaders set the tone for the entire organization, and this includes conflict resolution within the boardroom. 

Ask yourself the following questions:

• Are you comfortable raising tough topics and discussions?  
• Does your board feel safe expressing diverse perspectives and challenging your ideas?

If the answer is No, it’s time to learn the nature of the board and executive director conflicts.

1. Who’s the boss? Unclear boundaries between the board’s role and the CEO’s role in running things can cause problems. To be more specific, the board might micromanage, or the CEO might feel they have too much freedom.
2. Information blackout. When information isn’t shared openly, trust may be ruined. As a result, the board might feel the CEO is hiding problems, while the CEO might be afraid to share bad news for fear of losing support. Thus, executive reporting processes must be established in advance. 
3. Changing course. Sometimes new difficulties or opportunities might cause unexpected problems. For example, the board might push for a new direction, although the CEO may believe the current strategy is still the best option.
4. Opposites don’t always attract. Even highly experienced executives might find it difficult to work together if their approaches differ. For instance, the board chair who is extremely detail-oriented may have differing views from a CEO who is more focused on the larger picture.
5. Ego trips and ambition. Even with good intentions, personality conflicts can make things worse and affect decision-making. Sometimes board members or CEOs put their own interests ahead of what is best for the company.

Best practices for organizational governance

The success of all businesses depends on effective organizational governance, in which communication plays a significant role. We’ve gathered practical tips based on best communication practices between the C-suite and the boardroom. 

Conduct interactive meetings, not lectures

Meetings are crucial, but not when they turn into one-sided lectures. Instead, frame them as a chance for genuine business interactions and board discussions. Motivate board members to come prepared with questions and any pressing concerns they may have. 

The truth is that current information-sharing and task-alignment processes are falling short. In fact, 70% of board members in a 2019 McKinsey Global Board Survey reported feeling dissatisfied with these aspects.

Make technology your friend

While some may resist digitalization, the reality is that directors need constant access to critical information and effective collaboration tools. 

Indeed, 81% started using digital tools for their executives in 2021. Fortunately, secure online board portals have been proven as the perfect solution with numerous benefits for simplifying communication.  

For example, iDeals Boards brings together all your board materials, like agendas, minutes, and reports, in one place. This means you can access them from any device, at any time. Additionally, security is a major focus, with encryption and 2FA protecting documents and granular permissions restrictions. 

Build honesty and trust

Building trust is the foundation of good organizational governance, and that can’t happen without open communication. CEOs shouldn’t sugarcoat the situation — they need to be transparent about both wins and challenges. When a director is honest about problems, there is more space for collaboration with the board.

Before any board meeting, take a step back and consider the board’s perspective:

• What are their worries about the company?
• What information might they be missing? 

When you tailor your communication to address these concerns, it shows you care. Moreover, it makes your message land.  

Building relationships beyond reporting

Sure, board meetings are all about reports and data, but there’s more to a strong CEO-board relationship than just numbers. 

For example, grabbing coffee (it can be even online coffee break sessions) or scheduling one-on-one meetings with board members shows you care about their perspectives beyond the formal setting. Some casual chats create a space for open conversation, building trust and respect. 

When you connect as people, not just positions, communication becomes way easier for everyone in the long run. 

Key takeaways

1. Strong communication is critical for a successful relationship between the executive director and the board.
2. The board focuses on strategic planning, oversight, and governance, while the executive director handles day-to-day operations, management, and implementation.
3. Nonprofits face unique challenges in building strong board-executive relationships due to limited resources, board member turnover, and difficulty making objective decisions.
4. Common conflicts between the board and executive director include unclear boundaries, information blackouts, disagreements about changing course, and personality clashes.
5. Best practices for board and executive director communication include interactive board meetings, using secure online board portals, and building strong relationships.

DOWNLOAD PDF