Request sent. We will email your board portal access link shortly. Our account manager will contact you to discuss your project.
Winning the boardroom: How executives earn the board’s confidence

Winning the boardroom: How executives earn the board’s confidence

5 min read
Post link has been copied

Board meetings used to be about getting through the slides. Today, directors expect more: they want to read the materials in advance, spend the meeting in discussion, and get real value from the executives in front of them. 

In our recent webinar hosted in partnership with M&A Community, author and board advisor Beverly Behan, explained what that shift means for how executives prepare their materials, run their time in the room, and earn the board’s confidence.

This article recaps Beverly’s key points – you can watch the full webinar on-demand.

The presentation starts a week early

Over the past two decades there has been a fundamental shift in how executives engage with their boards, says Beverly. Whereas executives were once stuck in ‘reporting’ mode, there is now a focus on ‘collaborative oversight’ which makes better use of the board’s experience and expertise.

Boards still oversee the company, but they also want to use the expertise around the table. That changes the executive’s job and how they prepare for board meetings, beginning with the pre-reading materials.

“Your board presentation starts about a week before you even enter the boardroom,” says Beverly. Directors form their first judgment of an executive from the materials, including whether the executive understands the priorities and respects the board’s time.

Why board packs fall short

In a UK and Ireland survey of 1,000 directors, 65% rated their board materials weak or poor and only 1% rated them excellent. Just 38% said board books added any value, and 54% agreed that “finding the key messages in the board pack is like finding a needle in a haystack.” 

A US survey of 500 public company directors found only 13% rated their board books extremely effective.

Beverly says the causes are familiar. Packs are overloaded, executive summaries are weak or missing, and data is dumped without a story. Acronyms go unexplained, and slides cannot stand alone without a voiceover. 

Directors can digest about 30 pages an hour and typically spend four hours preparing, which is around 120 pages. Many packs are far longer. 

For executives, that is an opportunity. “If you’re an executive and you start hitting it out of the park in the board materials, you will really distinguish yourself,” she says.

Start with the executive summary

If an executive can only fix one thing, they’ll get the most impact by prioritizing the executive summary. 

“If you fix nothing but your executive summaries, that’s going to make a huge difference in terms of your board’s impression and how you engage with them,” she explains.

A strong summary has three parts: the ask, a sentence or two reminding directors how the topic reached this point, and four or five key takeaways. 

Beverly said a reader of the summary alone should know enough to join the discussion, and warned against “processy” summaries that contain too much in-depth background information.

She also encouraged using AI tools such as Microsoft Copilot to draft summaries from existing materials, then refining the result.

From presenter to facilitator

Once the materials are doing a proper job of informing the readers, the meeting changes. While in the past around 80% of a board slot went on walking through slides, Beverly says that ratio has flipped so the majority of the meeting is focused on discussions and decisions. 

“Executives have moved from being a presenter to a facilitator. You’ve moved from being an information provider to a discussion leader,” she explains.

In practice, she suggests stating your objective, giving a short recap with color commentary rather than reading bullets, and then opening with a question of your own. “The most impressive executives will turn and say, ‘I’d like to open the discussion with a question to the board,'” she says. 

This shows confidence and keeps the conversation at governance level, while keeping a few more questions in reserve helps if directors drift into operational detail.

Prepare for the questions

For Beverly, the Q&A is where confidence is won or lost. She recommends preparing 8-10 likely questions and rehearsing the answers. “Nothing looks more polished in a boardroom than an executive who’s prepared like that,” says Beverly.

AI tools, such as Claude or Copilot, can help here too. Beverly suggests giving it the board materials, the opening deck and director bios, then asking for governance-level questions those directors might raise. 

One purchasing executive she coached found three of the generated questions were “right on the money” and his chair later said he “hit it out of the park.” Her caution is that the answers must be in your own words, never read from a sheet.

If a question catches you off guard, Beverly advises asking for time to think and promising to come back within a day or two. Then follow through, because directors remember commitments that go unfulfilled. 

If requests for more detail pile up, raise it through the CEO and the board chair rather than pushing back yourself, since doing it directly can sound defensive.

Winning the board’s confidence

The common thread in Beverly’s advice is that confidence with a board requires diligence, preparation, and a recognition of what value the board should provide. 

Clear materials let directors arrive informed; a short recap and an open question turn the meeting into a conversation; careful preparation for the Q&A shows directors that you know your subject. 

As Beverly put it, “The Q&A has now become the most important part of the meeting, and that’s where you really build confidence.”

Executives who get these habits right don’t just survive the boardroom. They give directors a reason to look forward to hearing from them, and that is where influence starts.

This article covers only part of the discussion. Beverly also goes deeper on using Copilot to prepare, recovering when a question catches you off guard, and handling requests for ever more detail.

To hear it all in her own words, watch the full webinar recording.

Make your board meetings more efficient today