Request sent. We will email your board portal access link shortly. Our account manager will contact you to discuss your project.
Martha’s Rules of Order: A consensus-based alternative to Robert’s Rules

Martha’s Rules of Order: A consensus-based alternative to Robert’s Rules

8 min read
how to organize a meeting as a secretary
Post link has been copied

Martha’s Rules of Order offers a consensus-based alternative to Robert’s Rules of Order, letting members voice support or concerns before a formal vote. Anne Minahan described the procedure in 1986, drawing on decision-making practices at Martha’s Housing Co-op in Madison, Wisconsin.

A 2024 analysis by the American Association of University Professors highlights its five-step approach, which allows groups to gauge agreement through informal polls and discuss alternatives before introducing a formal motion.

This guide explains the steps, the sense vote, and a comparison with Robert’s Rules, then shows how a US board can adopt the procedure. It is educational and not legal advice, so confirm your bylaws and state law with counsel.

Key takeaways

  • Martha’s Rules is a five-step consensus procedure from a Madison housing co-op, described by Anne Minahan in 1986.
  • The sense vote measures support (like it, can live with it, uncomfortable) before the official vote.
  • Robert’s Rules structure motions, debate, and majority voting, while Martha’s Rules use a sense vote to surface objections before the final decision.
  • The rules suit small, collaborative boards but may be less practical for larger assemblies or organizations that must follow a different parliamentary authority.

What are Martha’s Rules of Order?

Martha’s Rules are a five-step, consensus-based meeting procedure developed at Martha’s Housing Co-op, a housing cooperative for families in Madison, Wisconsin. According to Minahan, members created them because they were dissatisfied with Robert’s Rules and wanted to understand and commit to their decisions. A 2026 adaptation counts six steps instead of five.

However, Minahan names a trade-off. Consensus can produce well-considered decisions but takes time and energy, and some decisions are not worth the effort. The sense vote tests whether an issue deserves a longer discussion.

A 2023 Ryan White program training guide dates the rules to the 1970s. The primary source is a four-page journal article, not a Martha’s Rules of Order book, and some guides spell the name “Martha rules of order.”

Martha’s Rules is one of several alternatives to Robert’s Rules of Order that boards consider. Afshan Jafar, chair of the AAUP’s governance committee, argues in a 2024 Academe article that faculty bodies can do better than the dense, rigid, and hierarchical system of Robert’s Rules. Although the article focuses on academic governance, it also discusses Martha’s Rules as a consensus-based alternative to Robert’s Rules.

The steps of Martha’s Rules of Order

The count of Martha’s Rules of Order steps depends on the source. Minahan lists five steps, and the Ontario Nonprofit Network lists six. ONN splits Minahan’s fourth step, a sense vote followed by a “vote” vote, into a sense vote and an official vote. Minahan notes that the steps are a framework, not a fixed script.

  1. Preparation. Members receive the topics in advance, and the facilitator proposes a time-limited agenda that the group accepts.
  2. Generating proposals. When an issue has no specific proposal, the group explores options and their effects for a limited time.
  3. Making proposals concrete. The facilitator turns ideas into specific proposals that state cost, authority, and who will do the work.
  4. Sense vote. Members say whether they like a proposal, can live with it, or are uncomfortable, and uncomfortable members explain why.
  5. Official vote. The group decides whether to adopt the proposal over the stated objections of the minority.
  6. Implementation and review. The facilitator restates the decision, assigns roles, and sets whether and when to review it.

Both versions describe the same core process. Minahan combines the sense vote and official vote into one step, while the Ontario Nonprofit Network lists them separately. Meeting minutes should distinguish between the two votes.

How the sense vote works

The sense vote is a hand count, taken once proposals are concrete, that asks three questions about each proposal: who likes it, who can live with it, and who is uncomfortable with it. Uncomfortable members then explain, and Minahan suggests two minutes each.

Minahan’s example uses a 20-person meeting and four proposals. The table restates her counts and recommended responses in plain wording, with a total column added by the editors.

ProposalLike itCan live with itUncomfortableTotalRecommended response
A661022Drop it, because support is too low
B74920Look for a more acceptable proposal, but still hold the “vote” vote
C87520Move to the “vote” vote
D315220Ask the five members with strong views to talk it through, because the group as a whole is indifferent

Proposal A totals 22 votes in the printed table, although the example describes 20 people. The source does not explain the difference, and the recommended response does not change.

Minahan explains “can live with it”: members may agree with the principle but doubt the steps, or may not care enough to block the idea. A majority of such votes may indicate the issue does not yet strongly interest the group.

The “uncomfortable” vote gives members a place to speak before the decision is final. Minahan reports seeing a committed majority drop a proposal after a late objection. If anyone is uncomfortable, the official vote asks whether the group will adopt the proposal over the minority’s objections when a majority finds it workable. If not, the group can write a new proposal, keep discussing, or return later.

Martha’s Rules vs. Robert’s Rules: Key differences

The two systems suit different organizations, so the comparison is about fit, not ranking.

FeatureMartha’s RulesRobert’s Rules
Decision philosophyConsensus-oriented, with majority vote as the fallbackMajority rule with protection for minority rights
FormalityLow, with steps that act as a flexible frameworkHigh, with detailed rules for motions and debate
Group sizeMinahan’s example has 20 people, and ONN sees a better fit for boards than for members’ meetingsBuilt for assemblies of any size, with relaxed rules for boards of about a dozen
How dissent is handledMembers voice objections in the sense vote, before the final voteMembers raise objections in debate before the vote and may vote against a motion
Document lengthA four-page article (Minahan, 1986)816 pages in the 12th edition (2020)
Best forSmall, collaborative boards with a trained facilitatorLarge or formal bodies, and bodies whose bylaws require it

BoardSource emphasizes that nonprofit directors should participate in informed decisions and exercise independent judgment.

Read more:

Want simpler parliamentary rules instead of consensus? Try Rosenberg’s Rules of Order, which keep majority voting with less formality.

Choose between Martha’s Rules and Robert’s Rules

When to use Martha’s Rules depends on size, culture, and legal requirements. BoardSource reports an average nonprofit board size of 15 and a median of 13, close to Minahan’s 20-person example.

Use Martha’s Rules when:

  • Your board has fewer than about 20 members (an editorial guideline, not a sourced limit);
  • Your culture is collaborative, as on a consensus decision-making board;
  • Members have no training in parliamentary procedure; and
  • Board meetings run long because disagreement stays unresolved.

Keep Robert’s Rules when your board is large, when your bylaws or state law require them, or when high-volume decisions must move fast. 

A middle path also works: use Martha’s Rules in committees and Robert’s Rules for the annual general meeting. ONN adds that the method needs training and a carefully chosen chair. Pair either system with a consent agenda so the group saves the sense vote for real decisions.

Protect directors’ rights when recording decisions

ONN analyzes Martha’s Rules under Ontario law, so US boards should adapt its points to their own state. BoardSource describes the duty of care as informed decision-making and lists failure to ask questions about a proposed action as an example of a potential breach. The sense vote asks every member directly, and the official vote shows that the board weighed objections.

Dissent needs one more step. Under Vermont’s Nonprofit Corporation Act, § 8.24(c), a director present when the board takes action generally assents unless an applicable statutory exception applies, such as recording dissent or abstention in the minutes or providing written notice before adjournment. 

An “uncomfortable” response is not a recorded dissent, so directors who wish to record formal dissent should avoid voting in favor and follow the procedures required by their state law, which may include recording dissent or abstention in the minutes or submitting timely written notice.

How to adopt Martha’s Rules for your board

A board can adopt Martha’s Rules through its bylaws or standing rules, depending on its governing documents and applicable law. The Robert’s Rules Association describes its own rules as default rules that bylaws and special rules of order override.

  • Review your bylaws and standing rules for a parliamentary authority clause.
  • Draft the amendment or rule. State that the board uses Martha’s Rules, set the vote threshold, and name the authority that covers anything else.
  • Train the board with a low-stakes practice run, such as choosing a meeting time.
  • Pilot the procedure in committee meetings first.
  • Standardize a proposal format that every sponsor uses.

For step two, the American Association of Philosophy Teachers adopted its own revision as standing rules in 2013. Its version adds an “uncertain” option and bars abstentions in the final vote, which may conflict with your statute or bylaws.

For step four, write the procedure into each committee’s charter. The guide on how to write a charter for a committee shows the usual structure.

For step five, use a simple Martha’s Rules of Order template. Each proposal states the issue, the specific action, the cost, who carries it out, who may vary the details, and the review date. ONN recommends naming who may vary details, because over-specific resolutions cause problems when plans change. Send each Martha’s Rules of Order agenda, with time limits, before the meeting.

Legal rules still apply. A board meeting quorum must be present before any vote counts as board action. Decisions without a meeting need written consent under your bylaws and state law. Some boards also use circular resolutions for urgent decisions, and your procedure should say how they are recorded.

Minutes matter more under this procedure. You can adapt the Robert’s Rules of Order meeting minutes format and add the sense vote counts and the official vote, labeled clearly, as ONN advises.

Organizations filing Form 990 must report significant changes to their governing documents in Part VI, line 4. Changes to standalone procedural policies generally do not require disclosure unless they also amend the governing documents.

A board portal such as Ideals Board, built for nonprofit boards, can send proposals before the meeting and keep vote counts and decisions in one record.

See how we can support your board meetings

Conclusion

Martha’s Rules give boards a clear, named way to hear objections before a vote. They fit small, collaborative boards that can train a facilitator, and they work best when bylaws, minutes, and state law are handled carefully. A board that must keep Robert’s Rules can still consider using a nonbinding sense vote for difficult items, where its governing rules permit.

FAQs

See how can we support your board meeting

Explore our comprehensive solution designed to optimize every aspect of your board meetings

Request sent
We will email your access link shortly. 
Our account manager will contact you to discuss your project.