Strategy and risk are supposed to move together, yet in most boardrooms they’re still treated as distinct conversations.
In a recent webinar hosted in partnership with M&A Community, board evaluator Sharon Constançon and governance specialist Ricardo Lemos explained why risk oversight keeps slipping down the agenda and what boards can do about it.
This article summarizes five key themes from the conversation, which you can now watch on-demand.
1. Risk is discussed, not acted on
Ricardo opened the discussion with a striking figure: only around one in five boards places risk management on the agenda in its own right. Where it does appear, it is usually delegated to an audit or risk committee, and the full board sees only an exception report.
The deeper problem is that risk isn’t built into strategy. “The result is that risk gets discussed constantly, but is rarely decided on,” he said. A board can be busy with risk topics and still never ask how much risk it is willing to take.
Sharon added that the split cuts both ways: strategy chases opportunity and forgets risk, while the risk committee manages risk and forgets opportunity.
2. Frameworks are a starting point, not an answer
When it comes to risk governance there are various frameworks that organizations can use. The speakers walked through options including COSO ERM, ISO 31000, Basel and Solvency II, and agreed there is no single right choice.
Sharon warned against over-engineering: “If you overdo the project, it becomes such a burden that it won’t actually be dynamic.”
Ricardo offered four tests for choosing which framework is right for your organization:
- Fit with the company’s complexity, sector and regulator.
- A common language across the organization.
- Clear ownership of each risk.
- Use in real decisions rather than “just described in a manual.”
Sharon also urged boards to keep their own short risk list, including the uncomfortable entries that rarely make the register, such as people risks and reputation.
3. Cybersecurity leads, and AI is catching up
Across the major risk surveys, cybersecurity sits at or near the top. Ricardo cited PwC research in which cybersecurity was the only risk to appear in the top three for all seven sectors studied.
“Most researchers indicate that 50% of companies have been hacked or suffered cyber attacks in the past year,” he said. “I like to say that the other 50% just don’t know they have been.”
AI is now rising quickly in board risk conversations, though many are struggling to know how to tackle it. Ricardo suggested boards start with basic questions, such as: do we have an up-to-date inventory of our AI systems, and are strategic decisions already being influenced by unaudited models?
Sharon argues that AI deserves no special treatment: “AI, like cyber, is just another business risk.”
She also noted a telling contradiction in boardrooms, where directors voice deep mistrust of AI and then approve its use anyway.
4. A human must own every AI decision
Both speakers returned repeatedly to accountability. Directors don’t need technical expertise, but they do need enough knowledge to ask good questions. “You don’t have to be an AI expert, but as a director, you should be a common-sense expert,” said Sharon.
She also stressed preparing for failure. Companies that admit mistakes and take responsibility have faced very different legal outcomes from those that blame the machine.
“I don’t care who made it, there’s a human that owns it, and you take it on the chin if you’ve got it wrong and learn how to fix it,” she said.
Ricardo agreed, noting that the major risk in a company is “the element that is situated between the chair and the keyboard.”
5. Risk stays fluid
A risk register reviewed once a year is a snapshot that quickly becomes out of date. Ricardo was clear that risk is dynamic: “It’s not a picture; it’s a movie, a film.”
His practical guidance was to review the top handful of risks every quarter, refresh the full register once or twice a year, and trigger out-of-cycle reviews after events such as an acquisition, a war or a leadership change.
However, he explained that fast-moving risks like cybersecurity and AI warrant more frequent attention.
Sharon pointed to the chair as the conductor who keeps the balance between “panic, passion, practical ownership, and mitigation.”
She also cautioned that heatmaps can hide low-probability, high-impact events, and suggested directors ask what would worry them most if they had to face a select committee.
What boards can do now
Ricardo and Sharon offered refreshingly simple advice to boards looking to make immediate changes to their risk governance. Ricardo’s recommendation is to “put risk appetite on the agenda as a board decision,” which links risk to strategy and gives the board a concrete way to say yes, no, or yes with conditions.
For a first step, he suggested picking the next significant decision, such as an investment or expansion, and asking management for a one-page view of what could go wrong.
Sharon’s advice was just as direct: apply good common sense, ask the difficult questions, and keep drilling down into topics to get the information you need.
Boards that do so will find risk stops being a compliance exercise and becomes part of how they govern.